Skip to Main content
🦀 Click here to order crabs for 4+ days in advance!
  • Mr. Bill's Fresh Seafood & The Fat Crab Cafe

Fresh blue crabs ready for cooking

Mr. Bill's Fresh Seafood & The Fat Crab Cafe

430 Harrisburg Ave, Lancaster, PA
Pickup Only
‌
‌
Daily Crab Menu (Sun - Thurs)
The Fat Crab Cafe
Mr. Bill's Seafood Market
Drinks

Featured Items

  • Fish & Chips

    Golden-battered fish of the day, crispy hand-cut fries, house tartar & lemon
    $19.50
  • Peeled and Deveined 21-25ct LG Steamed Shrimp, Steamed & Chilled

    Approx 1lb peeled & deveined from 21-25ct Shrimp, Central America, steamed with our pure spice and chilled
    $27.00

Daily Crab Menu (Sun - Thurs)

Hot Steamed Male Crabs

Call 717-299-2791 to order jumbo males or to confirm availability if your preferred size is out of stock online!
  • XL Range Male Crabs, Hot Steamed

    By the 1/2 dozen, dozen, 1/2 bushel, and bushel 1/2 Dozen: 6 crabs 1 Dozen: 12 crabs 1/2 Bushel: Approximately 2.25-2.75 dozen crabs Bushel: Approximately 4.5-5.5 dozen crabs
    $54.50+
  • Jumbo Range Male Crabs, Hot Steamed

    1/2 Dozen: 6 Crabs 1 Dozen: 12 Crabs 1/2 Bushel: Approximately 1.75-2.6 dozen crabs Bushel: Approximately 3.5-5.25 dozen crabs
    $62.50+

Hot Steamed Female Crabs

Call 717-299-2791 to confirm availability if your preferred size is out of stock online!
  • Small Range Female Crabs, Hot Steamed

    By the 1/2 dozen, dozen, 1/2 bushel, and bushel 1/2 Dozen: 6 crabs 1 Dozen: 12 crabs 1/2 Bushel: Approximately 4.5-6 dozen Bushel: Approximately 9-12 dozen
    $17.50+
  • Medium Range Female Crabs, Hot Steamed

    By the 1/2 dozen, dozen, 1/2 bushel, and bushel 1/2 Dozen: 6 crabs 1 Dozen: 12 crabs 1/2 Bushel: Approximately 3.75-4.5 dozen Bushel: Approximately 7.5-9 dozen
    $22.50+
  • LG Range Female Crabs, Hot Steamed

    By the 1/2 dozen, dozen, 1/2 bushel, and bushel 1/2 Dozen: 6 crabs 1 Dozen: 12 crabs 1/2 Bushel: Approximately 3.25-3.75 dozen Bushel: Approximately 6.5-7.5 dozen
    $32.50+
  • Jumbo Range Female Crabs, Hot Steamed

    By the 1/2 dozen, dozen, 1/2 bushel, and bushel 1/2 Dozen: 6 crabs 1 Dozen: 12 crabs 1/2 Bushel: Approximately 2.25-3.25 dozen Bushel: Approximately 4.5-6.5 dozen
    $42.50+

Live Male Crabs

Call 717-299-2791 to order jumbo males or to confirm availability if your preferred size is out of stock online!
  • XL Range Male Crabs, Live

    By the 1/2 dozen, dozen, 1/2 bushel, and bushel 1/2 Dozen: 6 crabs 1 Dozen: 12 crabs 1/2 Bushel: Approximately 2.25-2.75 dozen crabs Bushel: Approximately 4.5-5.5 dozen crabs
    $54.50+
  • Jumbo Range Male Crabs, Live

    1/2 Dozen: 6 Crabs 1 Dozen: 12 Crabs 1/2 Bushel: Approximately 1.75-2.6 dozen crabs Bushel: Approximately 3.5-5.25 dozen crabs
    $62.50+

Steamed Sweet Corn

  • Steamed Sweet Corn in Husk

    1 ear of fresh sweet corn trimmed and steamed in the husk with our signature crab spice
    $4.00

Crab Utensils & Accessories

  • Mr. Bill's Crab Mallet

    $2.49
  • Crab Paper, 4ft

    $4.00
  • Crab Paper, 6ft

    $6.00
  • Crab Knife

    Reusable and durable; a useful tool for even the most seasoned crab pickers
    $1.99

The Fat Crab Cafe

Specials

  • $15 Fish Po' Boy Combo

    Our delicious fried fish Po' boy with a cup of our own made Red Fisherman's chowder and side of potato chips and pickles. Your choice of sauce on the side. Option to substitute New England Clam Chowder for $1.25
    $15.00
  • Shrimp Squealers (6)

    Bacon-wrapped shrimp, deep fried, tossed in Hank's hot sauce with rancH on the side
    $15.00
  • Bacon Wrapped Scallops (5)

    Five all natural sea scallops wrapped in bacon, deep fried and served with a side of our sweet chili sauce
    $19.50

Seafood Boils

  • Fat Crab Boil

    Loaded with 9 Shrimp, 2 blue crab clusters, 4 oz andouille sausage, wide sliced onion, baby red potatoes, and 1 ear of corn split in 2, prepared in a spiced boil and finished with real melted butter
    $29.00

House Specialties

  • The Crabman

    Loaded seasoned fries piled with sweet crab meat & our signature melted cheese blend. Substitute Philly soft pretzel +1
    $16.50
  • Fish & Chips

    Golden-battered fish of the day, crispy hand-cut fries, house tartar & lemon
    $19.50
  • Fish Tacos

    Three crunchy corn or soft flour tortillas, blackened fish, topped with roasted red peppers, black beans, corn, and our seasoning served with house made salsa & crema
    $19.50
  • Shrimp Tacos

    Three crunchy corn or soft flour tortillas, blackened shrimp, topped with roasted red peppers, black beans, corn, and our seasoning served with house made salsa and crema
    $22.00

Sandwiches

  • Jumbo Lump Crab & Shrimp Roll

    A perfect combo of jumbo lump crab, plump shrimp, and celery, tossed in our creamy citrus herb mayo for a Maine-style cold roll.
    $39.00
  • Cold Lobster Roll

    1/3 lb lobster salad served on a toasted split top roll, served with chips and pickles on the side
    $49.00
  • Cold Lobster Roll, Half

    Half order of our Cold Lobster Roll. Lobster salad served on a toasted split top roll, served with chips and pickles on the side
    $25.00
  • Hot Lobster Roll

    1/3 lb claw & knuckle lobster meat warmed in butter served on a toasted split top roll, served with chips and pickles on the side
    $49.00
  • Hot Lobster Roll, Half

    Half order of our Hot Lobster Roll. Claw & knuckle lobster meat warmed in butter served on a toasted split top roll, served with chips and pickles on the side
    $25.00
  • Fresh Fish Sandwich

    Broiled, blackened, or batter fried, lettuce, tomato, onion on brioche with tartar sauce, chips, and a pickles on the side
    $15.00
  • Crab Cake Sandwich

    Our own Market Crab Cake, romaine, tomato, and red onion, served on brioche with chips and pickles on the side
    $25.00
  • Soft Shell Crab Sandwich

    Single or double flash fried soft shell crab, lettuce, tomato, onion on brioche with garlic lime aioli, served with chips and pickles on the side
    $19.00
  • Famous Fat Crab Sandwich

    A flash-fried soft shell crab and broiled market crab cake, lettuce, tomato, onion on brioche with garlic lime aioli, chips, and pickles on the side
    $37.00
  • Shrimp Caesar Wrap

    Lightly blackened shrimp, romaine, shaved Parmesan cheese, and Caesar dressing wrapped in a grilled soft flour tortilla, served with chips and pickles on the side
    $21.00
  • Po' Boy

    Fried fish of the day, fried shrimp, or fried oysters on a grilled split top bun, served plain, with chips and pickles on the side
    $12.00
  • Cheeseburger

    Grilled cheeseburger with lettuce, tomato, onion and citrus herb spread on brioche with chips and pickles on the side
    $13.00
  • The Clucker Sandwich

    Grilled or blackened chicken breast with citrus herb spread, lettuce, tomato & red onion on brioche with chips and pickles on the side
    $13.00

Dinner Menu

  • Dinner Platter

    Your choice of protein served with your choice of two sides and two sauces.
  • Poseidon's Plate

    Broiled fresh fish, shrimp, scallops, crab cake & crab claw
    $69.00

From the Steamer

  • Steamed Snow & Bairdi Crab Clusters

    1 lb frozen weight of sweet, tender snow crab, freshly steamed and served with rich melted butte
  • Steamed Snow & Bairdi Crab Clusters, 3 lb Pile

    3 pounds frozen weight of sweet, tender snow crab clusters, freshly steamed, piled up, and served with rich melted butter.
  • Steamed Red King Crab Legs

    1 lb frozen weight of sweet Red King Crab legs and portions, steamed and served w/ rich melted butter
  • Hot Steamed Shrimp

    1lb raw weight of medium or jumbo hot steamed shrimp

A la carte

  • Crab Cake

    Our own Market Crab Cake, broiled
    $22.00
  • Shrimp

    Peeled and deveined shrimp grilled, blackened, broiled, or fried. Approx 10 shrimp
    $12.00
  • Scallops

    Large all natural sea scallops grilled, blackened, broiled, or fried. Approx 7oz precooked weight
    $22.00
  • Fried Oysters

    Flash fried oysters. Approx 6-9 pcs
    $16.00
  • Fried Soft Shell Crab (1)

    Flash fried soft shell crab
    $19.00
  • Flounder

    $24.00
  • Cod

    Broiled, blackened, or fried. Approx 5-6oz raw weight
    $17.00
  • Tuna

    Grilled, blackened, or broiled. Approx 5-6oz raw weight
    $16.00
  • Salmon

    Fresh Norwegian salmon grilled, blackened, or broiled. Approx 5-6oz raw weight
    $17.00

Salads

  • Romaine Caesar

    Lettuce, Caesar dressing, croutons and parmesan
    $9.00
  • Garden Fresh Greens

    Cucumbers, carrots, tomatoes, and red onion
    $9.00

Soups

  • Red Fisherman's Chowder

    Aromatic tomato broth brimming with fresh seafood
    $7.25+
  • New England Clam Chowder

    Our fabulous from-scratch specialty. Hearty and creamy New England Clam Chowder
    $8.50+
  • Creamy Crab and Asparagus

    Made with blue crab meat and fresh asparagus
    $8.50+

Sides

  • Bacon Horseradish Potato Salad

    Our Own Made
    $4.50
  • Baked Macaroni & Cheese

    Our Own Made
    $5.50
  • Classic Creamy Slaw

    Our Own Made
    $4.50
  • Corn on the Cob

    Husked steamed corn on the cob
    $4.00
  • Fresh Fruit Salad

    Our Own Made
    $5.50
  • Fries

    Hot and crispy fries
    $5.50
  • Hot Vegetable

    Seasonal Hot Vegetables
    $4.50
  • Melted Butter

    2oz
    $2.00
  • Potato Chips

    $3.50
  • Cucumber Salad

    Our Own Made
    $4.50
  • Side House Salad

    Our Own Made
    $5.00
  • Warm Crab Corn Bread

    Our Own Made
    $4.50
  • Wild Rice

    $4.00

Sauces

  • Cocktail Sauce

    Our Own Made
    $1.00
  • Tartar Sauce

    Our Own Made
    $1.00
  • Garlic Aioli

    Our Own Made
    $1.00
  • Citrus Herb

    Our Own Made
    $1.00
  • Mignonette

    Our Own Made
    $1.00
  • Horseradish

    $1.00
  • Honey Mustard

    $1.00
  • Garden Ranch

    $1.00
  • Spicy Remoulade

    $1.00
  • House Vinegarette

    $1.00
  • Bleu Cheese

    $1.00

Desserts

  • Key Lime Pie

    Our own made, sweet and tart with whipped cream and graham cracker crust
    $7.50
  • Chocolate Layered Cake

    $5.00
  • Chocolate Chip Cookie

    Our own made chocolate chip cookie
    $3.00

Mr. Bill's Seafood Market

Smoked Salmon

  • Our Own Smoked Salmon

    Our own smoked salmon, approx 1 lb
    $35.00

Fresh Fish

Online fish varieties are limited compared to what we have in store. Call 717-299-2791 or stop in for for our most up to date availability for same-day or holiday preorders!
  • Atlantic Salmon, Scottish/Nor/Faroe Is.

    Fresh Scottish, Norwegian, or Faroe Island Atlantic Salmon, farm-raised, filleted, pin-bones removed, raw, skin-on, cut by hand. Approx 1 lb
    $27.00
  • Atlantic Salmon, Canadian

    Fresh Canadian Atlantic Salmon, farm-raised, filleted, pin-bones removed, raw, skin-on, cut by hand. Approx 1 lb
    $20.00
  • Wild Boston Blue

    Fresh wild Boston Blue (Pollock), filleted, skinless, raw, cut by hand. Approx 1 lb
    $19.00
  • Wild Cod

    Fresh wild Cod, filleted, skinless, raw. Approx 1 lb
    $27.00
  • Wild Nova Scotia Day Boat Halibut

    Wild Nova Scotia day boat halibut, filleted, skinless, raw, cut by hand. Approx 1 lb
    $45.00
  • Arctic Char

    Fresh arctic char, farm raised, filleted, skin-on, raw. Approx 1 lb
    $27.00
  • Saltwater Tilapia

    Saltwater tilapia, farm raised, filleted, skinless, raw. Approx 1 lb
    $9.00
  • Wild Yellowfin Ahi Tuna

    Fresh wild Yellowfin Ahi Tuna steaks, raw. Approx 1 lb
    $39.00
  • Wild Jumbo Flounder

    Fresh wild Jumbo Flounder, filleted, skinless, raw. Approx 1 lb
    $25.00
  • Haddock

    Fresh haddock filets, approx 1 lb
    $24.00

Shrimp

  • 31-35ct Medium Shrimp, Raw

    Raw Medium Shrimp (31-35ct) approx 1lb, shell-on, headless, Central America, previously frozen
    $12.00
  • 21-25ct LG Shrimp, Raw

    Raw XL Shrimp (21-25ct), approx 1lb, shell-on, headless, Central America, previously frozen
    $15.00
  • Jumbo U-15ct Shrimp, Raw

    Raw Jumbo Shrimp (U-15ct) approx 1lb, shell-on, headless, Central America, previously frozen
    $21.00
  • 21-25ct LG Shrimp, Steamed & Chilled

    Approx 1lb LG Shrimp (21-25ct), Central America, shell-on, steamed with our pure spice and chilled
    $19.00
  • Peeled and Deveined 21-25ct LG Shrimp, Raw

    Approx 1lb, peeled & deveined from 21-25ct Shrimp, Central America, raw
    $21.00
  • Peeled and Deveined 21-25ct LG Steamed Shrimp, Steamed & Chilled

    Approx 1lb peeled & deveined from 21-25ct Shrimp, Central America, steamed with our pure spice and chilled
    $27.00
  • 4 lb Box 21-25ct LG Shrimp, Shell-on, Raw, Frozen

    4 lb box of LG shrimp (21-25ct/lb), shell-on, headless, raw, frozen, farm raised, Central America
    $58.00
  • 5 lb Box 21-25ct LG Shrimp, Shell-on, Raw, Frozen

    5 lb box of LG shrimp (21-25ct/lb), shell-on, headless, raw, frozen, farm raised, Central America
    $72.00
  • 5 lb Box 16-20ct, XL Shrimp, Shell-on, Raw, Frozen

    5 lb box of XL shrimp (16-20ct/lb), shell-on, headless, raw, frozen, farm raised, Central America
    $82.00
  • 5 lb Box U-12 Jumbo Shrimp, Shell-on, Raw, Frozen

    Wild jumbo shrimp (U-12ct/lb), shell-on, headless, raw, frozen, Central America
    $99.00

Crab Legs & Clusters

  • Medium Snow Crab Clusters, Frozen (5-8oz)

    By the pound, 5-8oz Medium Snow Crab Clusters, frozen
    $25.00
  • Jumbo Snow Crab Clusters, Frozen (12oz+)

    By the pound, 12oz+ Jumbo Snow Crab Clusters, frozen
    $39.00
  • Frozen King Crab Legs & Claws, Jumbo

    XL King Crab Legs and Claws, by the pound
    $139.00
  • Med. Snow 5-8oz, 30lb Case

    $675.00
  • Jumbo Snow Crab Clusters, 12oz+, 20lb Box

    10 lb box of jumbo (12oz+) frozen snow crab clusters. Naturally sweet, tender meat. Perfect for steaming or boiling at home.
    $630.00
  • Huge Snow Crab Clusters, 14oz+, 20lb Case

    $882.00

Party Trays

  • Regular Shrimp Party Tray

    2.5 lb of tender #1 white shrimp of the Americas (approx 70) cooked with our house seasoning served on a party tray with our own made cocktail sauce.
    $89.00
  • Large Shrimp Party Tray

    5 lb of tender #1 white shrimp of the Americas (approx 140) cooked with our house seasoning served on a party tray with our own made cocktail sauce.
    $175.00
  • Regular Shrimp and Cocktail Crab Claw Party Tray

    1.25 lb of tender #1 white shrimp of the Americas (approx 70) cooked with our house seasoning and 12 oz of delicious blue crab cocktail claws served on a party tray with our own made cocktail sauce and spicy mustard dipping sauce.
    $99.00
  • Large Shrimp and Cocktail Crab Claw Party Tray

    2.5 lb of tender #1 white shrimp of the Americas (approx 70) cooked with our house seasoning and 24 oz of delicious blue crab cocktail claws served on a party tray with our own made cocktail sauce and spicy mustard dipping sauce.
    $185.00
  • Regular Cocktail Crab Claw Party Tray

    24oz of delicious blue crab cocktail crab claws served on a party tray with our own made spicy mustard dipping sauce.
    $99.00
  • Large Cocktail Crab Claw Party Tray

    48oz of delicious blue crab cocktail crab claws served on a party tray with our own made spicy mustard dipping sauce.
    $195.00
  • Regular Shrimp and Snow Crab Claw Party Tray

    1.25 lb of tender #1 white shrimp of the Americas (approx 35) cooked with our house spice and 12 oz of sweet and delicate snow crab cocktail claws served on a party tray with our own made cocktail sauce and creamy dill dipping sauce.
    $119.00
  • Large Shrimp and Snow Crab Claw Party Tray

    2.5 lbs of tender #1 white shrimp of the Americas (approx 70) cooked with our house spice and 24 oz of sweet and delicate snow crab cocktail claws served on a party tray with our own made cocktail sauce and creamy dill dipping sauce.
    $229.00
  • Regular Snow Crab Claw Party Tray

    24 oz of sweet and delicate snow crab cocktail claws served with creamy dill dipping sauce.
    $139.00
  • Large Snow Crab Claw Party Tray

    48 oz of sweet and delicate snow crab cocktail claws served with creamy dill dipping sauce.
    $278.00

Oysters, Clams, and Mussels

Call 717-299-2791 for customized shucking orders!
  • Clam Raw Bar to Go (1 Dozen)

    1 dozen shucked top neck clams with your choice of horseradish, cocktail sauce, lemon sliced, and/or mignonette sauce. Cold-packed in a lidded aluminum tray for fresh and convenient transport.
    $36.00
  • Live PEI Mussels - 2lb Bag

    Mussels from Prince Edward Island, Canada
    $12.00
  • Little Neck Clams, Live

    Live little neck clams. Small, sweet and tender, perfect for steaming
  • Middle Neck Clams, Live

    Live middle neck clams, slightly larger than little neck clams, great for steaming
  • Top Neck Clams, Live

    Live medium-large top neck clams, great for eating raw on the half-shell or frying
  • Cherrystone Clams, Live

    Our largest clam, excellent for soups and chowders
  • Oyster Raw Bar to Go (1 Dozen)

    1 dozen fresh oysters shucked on the half shell. Served with your choice of cocktail sauce, mignonette sauce, horseradish, and sliced lemon on the side. Cold-packed in a lidded aluminum tray for convenient transport. Ready to serve!
    $42.00
  • Chesapeake Bay Oysters

    Fresh Chesapeake Bay Oysters, in the shell (not shucked)
    $1.00
  • Box of Chesapeake Bay Oysters (Approx 100ct)

    Box of fresh Chesapeake Bay Oysters, in the shell (not shucked), appox 100ct
    $95.00
  • Wellfleet Oysters

    Fresh Wellfleet oysters, in the shell (not shucked), by the piece
    $2.25
  • Barnstable Oysters

    Fresh Barnstable oysters, in the shell (not shucked), by the piece
    $2.25
  • Moondancer Oysters

    Fresh Moondancer oysters, in the shell (not shucked), by the piece
    $2.25
  • Duxbury Oysters

    Fresh Duxbury oysters, in the shell (not shucked), by the piece
    $2.25
  • Standard Oysters, Pint

    Shucked Chesapeake or Virginia standard size Oysters
    $27.00
  • Select Oysters, Pint

    Shucked Chesapeake or Virginia select size Oysters
    $27.00

Crab Cakes

  • Jumbo Lump Crab Cake

    Our own made jumbo lump crab cake (1) unbreaded, frozen, by the piece
    $17.00
  • Backfin/Lump Crab Cake

    Our own made backfin/lump crab cake (1) unbreaded, frozen, by the piece
    $12.00
  • Claw Crab Cake

    Our own made claw crab cake (1) unbreaded, frozen, by the piece
    $10.00

Crab Meat

  • Jumbo Lump Crab Meat, Maryland, Fresh

    1 lb of fresh Maryland jumbo lump crab meat
    $79.00
  • Lump Crab Meat, Maryland, Fresh

    1 lb of fresh Maryland lump crab meat,
    $59.00
  • Jumbo Lump Crab Meat, Mexico, Fresh

    $69.00
  • Lump Crab Meat, Mexico, Fresh

    $39.00
  • Claw Crab Meat, Mexico, Pasteurized

    $29.00
  • Cocktail Crab Claws, 12oz, Mexico, Pasteurized

    $49.00
  • Cocktail Crab Claws, 1LB, Louisiana

    1 lb of Louisiana cocktail crab claws
    $45.00

Soft Shell Crabs

  • Fresh Soft Shell Crab

    One (1) soft shell crab. Your choice of cleaned or live
    $12.00
  • Frozen Soft Shell Crab

    One (1) soft shell crab, frozen
    $13.00

Frozen

  • Domestic Calamari

    1lb, cleaned, tubes and tentacles, frozen
    $16.00
  • Conch

    Caribbean, 100% cleaned, 5lb box, frozen
    $89.00
  • Breaded Shrimp

    16-20ct, 3 lb box, frozen
    $27.00
  • Escargot

    10ct in shell w/ garlic butter, frozen
    $12.00

Sauces, Seasonings, and More

  • Crab Spice

    A perfect blend of coarse salt and pure spice for blue crabs
  • Pure Spice

    A perfect blend of spices for shrimp, snow & king crab, fish, shrimp, chicken, and more
  • Our Own Cocktail Sauce (1/2 Pint)

    Our own made cocktail sauce
    $5.00
  • Whole Lemon

    Whole fresh lemon
    $1.00

Drinks

  • Root Beer

    Fountain Barq's Root Beer
    $3.00
  • Coca-Cola

    Fountain Coke
    $3.00
  • Diet Coke

    Fountain Diet Coke
    $3.00
  • Coca-Cola Cherry

    Fountain Cherry Coke
    $3.00
  • Sprite, Fountain

    Fountain Sprite
    $3.00
  • Lemonade

    Fountain MinuteMaid Lemonade
    $3.00
  • Coca-Cola, Glass Bottle

    $3.29
  • Sprite Bottle

    $3.49
  • Hot Coffee

    $3.00
  • Iced Tea

    Unsweetened
    $3.00
  • S. Pellegrino Sparkling Water

    $3.29
  • Boylan Creme Soda

    $3.29
  • Boylan Ginger Ale

    $3.29
  • Boylan Birch Beer

    $3.29
  • Boylan Orange Soda

    $3.29
  • Boylan Root Beer

    $3.29

Mr. Bill's Fresh Seafood & The Fat Crab Cafe Location and Hours

(717) 299-2791
430 Harrisburg Ave, Lancaster, PA 17603
Closed • Opens Thursday at 11AM
Facebook logoInstagram logoFacebook logoInstagram logo
Toast logopowered by toast
  • Terms of Service
  • |Privacy Statement