Skip to Main content
🦀 Click here to order crabs for 4+ days in advance!
  • Mr. Bill's Fresh Seafood & The Fat Crab Cafe

Fresh blue crabs ready for cooking

Mr. Bill's Fresh Seafood & The Fat Crab Cafe

430 Harrisburg Ave, Lancaster, PA
Pickup Only
‌
‌
The Fat Crab Cafe
Mr. Bill's Seafood Market
Drinks

Featured Items

  • Fish & Chips

    Golden-battered fish of the day, crispy hand-cut fries, house tartar & lemon
    $19.50
  • Dinner Platter

    Your choice of protein served with your choice of two sides and two sauces.
  • Hot Lobster Roll

    1/3 lb claw & knuckle lobster meat warmed in butter served on a toasted split top roll, served with chips and pickles on the side
    $49.00

The Fat Crab Cafe

Specials

  • $15 Fish Po' Boy Combo

    Our delicious fried fish Po' boy with a cup of our own made Red Fisherman's chowder and side of potato chips and pickles. Your choice of sauce on the side. Option to substitute New England Clam Chowder for $1.25
    $15.00
  • Shrimp Squealers (6)

    Bacon-wrapped shrimp, deep fried, tossed in Hank's hot sauce with rancH on the side
    $15.00
  • Bacon Wrapped Scallops (5)

    Five all natural sea scallops wrapped in bacon, deep fried and served with a side of our sweet chili sauce
    $19.50

House Specialties

  • The Crabman

    Loaded seasoned fries piled with sweet crab meat & our signature melted cheese blend. Substitute Philly soft pretzel +1
    $16.50
  • Fish & Chips

    Golden-battered fish of the day, crispy hand-cut fries, house tartar & lemon
    $19.50
  • Fish Tacos

    Three crunchy corn or soft flour tortillas, blackened fish, topped with roasted red peppers, black beans, corn, and our seasoning served with house made salsa & crema
    $19.50
  • Shrimp Tacos

    Three crunchy corn or soft flour tortillas, blackened shrimp, topped with roasted red peppers, black beans, corn, and our seasoning served with house made salsa and crema
    $22.00

Sandwiches

  • Jumbo Lump Crab & Shrimp Roll

    A perfect combo of jumbo lump crab, plump shrimp, and celery, tossed in our creamy citrus herb mayo for a Maine-style cold roll.
    $39.00
  • Cold Lobster Roll

    1/3 lb lobster salad served on a toasted split top roll, served with chips and pickles on the side
    $49.00
  • Hot Lobster Roll

    1/3 lb claw & knuckle lobster meat warmed in butter served on a toasted split top roll, served with chips and pickles on the side
    $49.00
  • Fresh Fish Sandwich

    Broiled, blackened, or batter fried, lettuce, tomato, onion on brioche with tartar sauce, chips, and a pickles on the side
    $15.00
  • Crab Cake Sandwich

    Our own Market Crab Cake, romaine, tomato, and red onion, served on brioche with chips and pickles on the side
    $25.00
  • Soft Shell Crab Sandwich

    Single or double flash fried soft shell crab, lettuce, tomato, onion on brioche with garlic lime aioli, served with chips and pickles on the side
    $19.00
  • Famous Fat Crab Sandwich

    A flash-fried soft shell crab and broiled market crab cake, lettuce, tomato, onion on brioche with garlic lime aioli, chips, and pickles on the side
    $37.00
  • Shrimp Caesar Wrap

    Lightly blackened shrimp, romaine, shaved Parmesan cheese, and Caesar dressing wrapped in a grilled soft flour tortilla, served with chips and pickles on the side
    $21.00
  • Po' Boy

    Fried fish of the day, fried shrimp, or fried oysters on a grilled split top bun, served plain, with chips and pickles on the side
    $12.00
  • Cheeseburger

    Grilled cheeseburger with lettuce, tomato, onion and citrus herb spread on brioche with chips and pickles on the side
    $13.00
  • The Clucker Sandwich

    Grilled or blackened chicken breast with citrus herb spread, lettuce, tomato & red onion on brioche with chips and pickles on the side
    $13.00

Dinner Menu

  • Dinner Platter

    Your choice of protein served with your choice of two sides and two sauces.
  • Poseidon's Plate

    Broiled fresh fish, shrimp, scallops, crab cake & crab claw
    $69.00

From the Steamer

  • Steamed Snow & Bairdi Crab Clusters

    1 lb frozen weight of sweet, tender snow crab, freshly steamed and served with rich melted butte
  • Steamed Snow & Bairdi Crab Clusters, 3 lb Pile

    3 pounds frozen weight of sweet, tender snow crab clusters, freshly steamed, piled up, and served with rich melted butter.
  • Steamed Red King Crab Legs

    1 lb frozen weight of sweet Red King Crab legs and portions, steamed and served w/ rich melted butter
  • Hot Steamed Shrimp

    1lb raw weight of medium or jumbo hot steamed shrimp

A la carte

  • Crab Cake

    Our own Market Crab Cake, broiled
    $22.00
  • Shrimp

    Peeled and deveined shrimp grilled, blackened, broiled, or fried. Approx 10 shrimp
    $12.00
  • Scallops

    Large all natural sea scallops grilled, blackened, broiled, or fried. Approx 7oz precooked weight
    $22.00
  • Fried Oysters

    Flash fried oysters. Approx 6-9 pcs
    $16.00
  • Fried Soft Shell Crab (1)

    Flash fried soft shell crab
    $19.00
  • Cod

    Broiled, blackened, or fried. Approx 5-6oz raw weight
    $17.00
  • Tuna

    Grilled, blackened, or broiled. Approx 5-6oz raw weight
    $16.00
  • Salmon

    Fresh Norwegian salmon grilled, blackened, or broiled. Approx 5-6oz raw weight
    $17.00

Salads

  • Romaine Caesar

    Lettuce, Caesar dressing, croutons and parmesan
    $9.00
  • Garden Fresh Greens

    Cucumbers, carrots, tomatoes, and red onion
    $9.00

Soups

  • Red Fisherman's Chowder

    Aromatic tomato broth brimming with fresh seafood
    $7.25+
  • New England Clam Chowder

    Our fabulous from-scratch specialty. Hearty and creamy New England Clam Chowder
    $8.50+
  • Creamy Shrimp and Corn Chowder

    Made with tender shrimp and sweet corn
    $8.50+
  • Crab and Corn Chowder🦀🌽

    Made with blue crab meat and sweet corn
    $8.50+

Sides

  • Bacon Horseradish Potato Salad

    Our Own Made
    $4.50
  • Baked Macaroni & Cheese

    Our Own Made
    $5.50
  • Classic Creamy Slaw

    Our Own Made
    $4.50
  • Fresh Fruit Salad

    Our Own Made
    $5.50
  • Fries

    Hot and crispy fries
    $5.50
  • Hot Vegetable

    Seasonal Hot Vegetables
    $4.50
  • Melted Butter

    2oz
    $2.00
  • Potato Chips

    $3.50
  • Cucumber Salad

    Our Own Made
    $4.50
  • Side House Salad

    Our Own Made
    $5.00
  • Warm Crab Corn Bread

    Our Own Made
    $4.50
  • Wild Rice

    $4.00

Sauces

  • Cocktail Sauce

    Our Own Made
    $1.00
  • Tartar Sauce

    Our Own Made
    $1.00
  • Garlic Aioli

    Our Own Made
    $1.00
  • Citrus Herb

    Our Own Made
    $1.00
  • Mignonette

    Our Own Made
    $1.00
  • Horseradish

    $1.00
  • Honey Mustard

    $1.00
  • Garden Ranch

    $1.00
  • Spicy Remoulade

    $1.00
  • House Vinegarette

    $1.00
  • Bleu Cheese

    $1.00

Desserts

  • Key Lime Pie

    Our own made, sweet and tart with whipped cream and graham cracker crust
    $7.50
  • Chocolate Chip Cookie

    Our own made chocolate chip cookie
    $3.00

Mr. Bill's Seafood Market

Smoked Salmon

  • Our Own Smoked Salmon

    Our own smoked salmon, approx 1 lb
    $35.00

Fresh Fish

Online fish varieties are limited compared to what we have in store. Call 717-299-2791 or stop in for for our most up to date availability for same-day or holiday preorders!
  • WIld Coho Salmon

    Fresh Wild Coho Salmon, filleted, raw, skin-on, cut by hand. Approx 1 lb
    $27.00
  • Atlantic Salmon, Scottish/Nor/Faroe Is.

    Fresh Scottish, Norwegian, or Faroe Island Atlantic Salmon, farm-raised, filleted, raw, skin-on, cut by hand. Approx 1 lb
    $27.00
  • Atlantic Salmon, Canadian

    Fresh Canadian Atlantic Salmon, farm-raised, filleted, raw, skin-on, cut by hand. Approx 1 lb
    $20.00
  • Wild Nova Scotia Day Boat Halibut

    Wild Nova Scotia day boat halibut, filleted, skinless, raw, cut by hand. Approx 1 lb
    $39.00
  • Wild Boston Blue

    Fresh wild Boston Blue (Pollock), filleted, skinless, raw, cut by hand. Approx 1 lb
    $22.00
  • Wild Cod

    Fresh wild Cod, filleted, skinless, raw. Approx 1 lb
    $27.00
  • Saltwater Tilapia

    Saltwater tilapia, farm raised, filleted, skinless, raw. Approx 1 lb
    $9.00
  • Wild Yellowfin Ahi Tuna

    Fresh wild Yellowfin Ahi Tuna steaks, raw. Approx 1 lb
    $39.00
  • Haddock

    Fresh haddock filets, approx 1 lb
    $24.00

Shrimp

  • 31-35ct Medium Shrimp, Raw

    Raw Medium Shrimp (31-35ct) approx 1lb, shell-on, headless, Central America, previously frozen
    $12.00
  • 21-25ct LG Shrimp, Raw

    Raw XL Shrimp (21-25ct), approx 1lb, shell-on, headless, Central America, previously frozen
    $15.00
  • Jumbo U-15ct Shrimp, Raw

    Raw Jumbo Shrimp (U-15ct) approx 1lb, shell-on, headless, Central America, previously frozen
    $21.00
  • 21-25ct LG Shrimp, Steamed & Chilled

    Approx 1lb LG Shrimp (21-25ct), Central America, shell-on, steamed with our pure spice and chilled
    $19.00
  • Peeled and Deveined 21-25ct LG Shrimp, Raw

    Approx 1lb, peeled & deveined from 21-25ct Shrimp, Central America, raw
    $21.00
  • Peeled and Deveined 21-25ct LG Steamed Shrimp, Steamed & Chilled

    Approx 1lb peeled & deveined from 21-25ct Shrimp, Central America, steamed with our pure spice and chilled
    $27.00
  • 4 lb Box 21-25ct LG Shrimp, Shell-on, Raw, Frozen

    4 lb box of LG shrimp (21-25ct/lb), shell-on, headless, raw, frozen, farm raised, Central America
    $58.00
  • 5 lb Box 21-25ct LG Shrimp, Shell-on, Raw, Frozen

    5 lb box of LG shrimp (21-25ct/lb), shell-on, headless, raw, frozen, farm raised, Central America
    $72.00
  • 5 lb Box 16-20ct, XL Shrimp, Shell-on, Raw, Frozen

    5 lb box of XL shrimp (16-20ct/lb), shell-on, headless, raw, frozen, farm raised, Central America
    $82.00
  • 5 lb Box U-12 Jumbo Shrimp, Shell-on, Raw, Frozen

    Wild jumbo shrimp (U-12ct/lb), shell-on, headless, raw, frozen, Central America
    $99.00

Crab Legs & Clusters

  • Medium Snow Crab Clusters, Frozen (5-8oz)

    By the pound, 5-8oz Medium Snow Crab Clusters, frozen
    $25.00
  • XL Snow Crab Clusters, Frozen (10oz+)

    By the pound, 10oz+ XL Snow Crab Clusters, frozen
    $35.00
  • Jumbo Snow Crab Clusters, Frozen (12oz+)

    By the pound, 12oz+ Jumbo Snow Crab Clusters, frozen
    $39.00
  • Huge Snow/Bairdi Crab Clusters, Frozen (14oz+)

    By the pound, 14oz+ Huge Snow or Bairdi Crab Clusters, frozen
    $49.00
  • Frozen King Crab Legs & Claws, Jumbo

    XL King Crab Legs and Claws, by the pound
    $139.00
  • Med. Snow 5-8oz, 30lb Case

    $675.00
  • Jumbo Snow Crab Clusters, 12oz+, 20lb Box

    10 lb box of jumbo (12oz+) frozen snow crab clusters. Naturally sweet, tender meat. Perfect for steaming or boiling at home.
    $630.00
  • Huge Snow Crab Clusters, 14oz+, 20lb Case

    $882.00

Party Trays

  • Regular Shrimp Party Tray

    2.5 lb of tender #1 white shrimp of the Americas (approx 70) cooked with our house seasoning served on a party tray with our own made cocktail sauce.
    $89.00
  • Large Shrimp Party Tray

    5 lb of tender #1 white shrimp of the Americas (approx 140) cooked with our house seasoning served on a party tray with our own made cocktail sauce.
    $175.00
  • Regular Shrimp and Cocktail Crab Claw Party Tray

    1.25 lb of tender #1 white shrimp of the Americas (approx 70) cooked with our house seasoning and 12 oz of delicious blue crab cocktail claws served on a party tray with our own made cocktail sauce and spicy mustard dipping sauce.
    $99.00
  • Large Shrimp and Cocktail Crab Claw Party Tray

    2.5 lb of tender #1 white shrimp of the Americas (approx 70) cooked with our house seasoning and 24 oz of delicious blue crab cocktail claws served on a party tray with our own made cocktail sauce and spicy mustard dipping sauce.
    $185.00
  • Regular Cocktail Crab Claw Party Tray

    24oz of delicious blue crab cocktail crab claws served on a party tray with our own made spicy mustard dipping sauce.
    $99.00
  • Large Cocktail Crab Claw Party Tray

    48oz of delicious blue crab cocktail crab claws served on a party tray with our own made spicy mustard dipping sauce.
    $195.00
  • Regular Shrimp and Snow Crab Claw Party Tray

    1.25 lb of tender #1 white shrimp of the Americas (approx 35) cooked with our house spice and 12 oz of sweet and delicate snow crab cocktail claws served on a party tray with our own made cocktail sauce and creamy dill dipping sauce.
    $119.00
  • Large Shrimp and Snow Crab Claw Party Tray

    2.5 lbs of tender #1 white shrimp of the Americas (approx 70) cooked with our house spice and 24 oz of sweet and delicate snow crab cocktail claws served on a party tray with our own made cocktail sauce and creamy dill dipping sauce.
    $229.00
  • Regular Snow Crab Claw Party Tray

    24 oz of sweet and delicate snow crab cocktail claws served with creamy dill dipping sauce.
    $139.00
  • Large Snow Crab Claw Party Tray

    48 oz of sweet and delicate snow crab cocktail claws served with creamy dill dipping sauce.
    $278.00

Oysters, Clams, and Mussels

Call 717-299-2791 for customized shucking orders!
  • Clam Raw Bar to Go (1 Dozen)

    1 dozen shucked top neck clams with your choice of horseradish, cocktail sauce, lemon sliced, and/or mignonette sauce. Cold-packed in a lidded aluminum tray for fresh and convenient transport.
    $36.00
  • Live PEI Mussels - 2lb Bag

    Mussels from Prince Edward Island, Canada
    $14.00
  • Little Neck Clams, Live

    Live little neck clams. Small, sweet and tender, perfect for steaming
  • Middle Neck Clams, Live

    Live middle neck clams, slightly larger than little neck clams, great for steaming
  • Top Neck Clams, Live

    Live medium-large top neck clams, great for eating raw on the half-shell or frying
  • Soft Shell Clams, Live, by the pound

    Ipswich clams, famously known as "steamers" or "soft-shell clams," are a highly prized delicacy. They are universally celebrated for their sweet, briny flavor and distinct, tender "whole bellies". Sold live and by the pound.
    $11.99
  • Oyster Raw Bar to Go (1 Dozen)

    1 dozen fresh oysters shucked on the half shell. Served with your choice of cocktail sauce, mignonette sauce, horseradish, and sliced lemon on the side. Cold-packed in a lidded aluminum tray for convenient transport. Ready to serve!
    $42.00
  • Mama Mia Oysters

    Fresh Mama Mia oysters, in the shell (not shucked), by the piece
    $2.25
  • Sweet Petite Oysters

    Fresh Sweet Petite oysters, in the shell (not shucked), by the piece
    $2.25
  • Duxbury Oysters

    Fresh Duxbury oysters, in the shell (not shucked), by the piece
    $2.25
  • Standard Oysters, Pint

    Shucked Chesapeake or Virginia standard size Oysters
    $27.00
  • Select Oysters, Pint

    Shucked Chesapeake or Virginia select size Oysters
    $27.00

Crab Cakes

  • Jumbo Lump Crab Cake

    Our own made jumbo lump crab cake (1) unbreaded, frozen, by the piece
    $17.00
  • Claw Crab Cake

    Our own made claw crab cake (1) unbreaded, frozen, by the piece
    $10.00

Crab Meat

  • Jumbo Lump Crab Meat, Maryland, Fresh

    1 lb of fresh Maryland jumbo lump crab meat
    $79.00
  • Lump Crab Meat, Maryland, Fresh

    1 lb of fresh Maryland lump crab meat,
    $59.00
  • Jumbo Lump Crab Meat, Mexico, Fresh

    $69.00
  • Lump Crab Meat, Mexico, Fresh

    $39.00
  • Claw Crab Meat, Mexico, Pasteurized

    $29.00
  • Cocktail Crab Claws, 12oz, Mexico, Pasteurized

    $49.00
  • Cocktail Crab Claws, 1LB, Louisiana

    1 lb of Louisiana cocktail crab claws
    $45.00
  • Lump Crab Meat, Louisiana

    1 lb of Louisiana lump/backfin crab meat
    $49.00

Soft Shell Crabs

  • Fresh Soft Shell Crab

    One (1) soft shell crab. Your choice of cleaned or live
    $12.00
  • Frozen Soft Shell Crab

    One (1) soft shell crab, frozen
    $13.00

Frozen

  • Domestic Calamari

    1lb, cleaned, tubes and tentacles, frozen
    $16.00
  • Breaded Shrimp

    16-20ct, 3 lb box, frozen
    $27.00
  • Escargot

    10ct in shell w/ garlic butter, frozen
    $12.00

Sauces, Seasonings, and More

  • Crab Spice

    A perfect blend of coarse salt and pure spice for blue crabs
  • Pure Spice

    A perfect blend of spices for shrimp, snow & king crab, fish, shrimp, chicken, and more
  • Our Own Cocktail Sauce (1/2 Pint)

    Our own made cocktail sauce
    $5.00
  • Whole Lemon

    Whole fresh lemon
    $1.00

Drinks

  • Root Beer

    Fountain Barq's Root Beer
    $3.00
  • Coca-Cola

    Fountain Coke
    $3.00
  • Diet Coke

    Fountain Diet Coke
    $3.00
  • Coca-Cola Cherry

    Fountain Cherry Coke
    $3.00
  • Sprite, Fountain

    Fountain Sprite
    $3.00
  • Lemonade

    Fountain MinuteMaid Lemonade
    $3.00
  • Coca-Cola, Glass Bottle

    $3.29
  • Sprite Bottle

    $3.49
  • Hot Coffee

    $3.00
  • Iced Tea

    Unsweetened
    $3.00
  • Boylan Grape Soda

    $3.29
  • Boylan Ginger Ale

    $3.29
  • Boylan Birch Beer

    $3.29
  • Boylan Orange Soda

    $3.29
  • Boylan Root Beer

    $3.29

Peeled and Deveined 21-25ct LG Steamed Shrimp, Steamed & Chilled

$27.00

Approx 1lb peeled & deveined from 21-25ct Shrimp, Central America, steamed with our pure spice and chilled

Request advisory
We'll do our best to accommodate special requests but may not be able to honor all substitutes. Extra charges may apply.
1

Mr. Bill's Fresh Seafood & The Fat Crab Cafe Location and Hours

(717) 299-2791
430 Harrisburg Ave, Lancaster, PA 17603
Closed • Opens Tuesday at 11AM
Facebook logoInstagram logoFacebook logoInstagram logo
Toast logopowered by toast
  • Terms of Service
  • |Privacy Statement